James Jermain went to Dufour's home port of La Rochelle
for the launch of its new generation of fast
cruising yachts
by James Jermain
Yachting Monthly - January 2003
From her aggressive bow sections to her
low-profile topsides, stylish super structure and
royal blue paint work, the new Dufour is a striking
boat. She is the first of a new range in which style
and performance are high priorities. The formula
sounds Italian and the boat looks like a Grand
Soleil. Coincidence ? Not really. Dufour and Grand
Soleil are in the same group and Umberto Felci
designs hulls for both.
Design
The lines of the Dufour 40 reflect the current
trend towards bows with pronounced hollow and very
fine entry. The waterline then sweeps out to a
moderate beam, which reaches its maximum well aft of
amidships before tucking in gently to a transom
which is also moderate. Below the waterline, the
hull is a balance between fine sections for speed
and volume for load carrying and family cruising.
This balance looked to us to be struck toward the
performance end of the spectrum. The keel is a
high-aspect fin with a substantial bulb at the foot
and moderate draft. The rudder is a very slim spade.
Below Decks
There is little evidence of the compromise
between speed and comfort below decks, where Patrick
Roseo has made a good job of creating a layout with
appeal across a broad spectrum, from couples on
their own to families or even charter parties. The
version we sailed had been optimized for a crew of
six in three double cabins with two heads. Other
versions include two cabins and a single head or
three cabins and a single head. Our test boat was a
prototype so we were disappointed but not overly
surprised, to find a few building blemishes and some
areas that had not been thought through to their
final form. However, we have seen many modifications
fitted to subsequent boats in the factory.
Whichever layout option is chosen, the middle
third of the boat remains the same. This is arranged
conventionally, with an L-shaped galley to prot of
the companionway, a head to starboard and the saloon
stretching right across the boat ahead of them.
Because she carries her beam well aft, the
accommodation is at its widest where width is most
needed, in the area of the heads and galley. By the
time you reach the saloon, beam has reduced
considerably, so she does not suffer from the
wide-open spaces which can make saloons of this size
impersonal and, at sea, exposed. Our boat was warmly
fitted out in cherry, but subsequent models will be
in light mahogany.
The dinette to port is a shallow C-shape with
easy access round the table. Opposite is a short
settee, which increases seating round the table to a
comfortable six with the leaf up, but which is too
short, at 1.63m (5ft 4in) to be used for sleeping.
The port bunk, though is 2.05m (6ft 9in) long
without removing the seat cushions. The table is
firmly mounted and has shallow fiddles. There is a
large bottle locker in the central section and the
portside leaf drops down to create a double bunk.
Stowage either side of the saloon is good, in the
form of two deeply fiddled and well-ventilated
lockers either side of a bookshelf. The locker doors
are supported by struts which seemed to us too
fragile. Behind the settees are long, unfiddled
shelves and the settee backs remove to reveal more
small lockers. There is further stowage in the seat
bases.
The saloon is reasonably well lit and ventilated.
There is an overhead hatch, two long, narrow windows
in the hull and two opening and two fixed port
lights in the coachroof. Overhead, there are eight
halogen spotlights but no reading lights. The area
is unusually well supplied with grab rails, which
make it very safe at sea.
Our boat was fitted with two after cabins and the
extra head in the fore cabin. Having seen the
alternative version at the Southampton Show, we can
say that the single head certainly allows for a
better fore cabin. The advantage of the format we
tested is that the occupier of the fore cabin has a
head en suite, which is what owners of 12.3m (40ft)
sailboats seem to expect these days.
The head compartment does push the bunk slightly
forward, making the foot of the bunk narrow; but
since it is 2.29m (7ft 6in) long, the last half
meter is not really needed. At shoulder level the
bunk 1.66m (5ft 6in) wide. The cabin has a spacious
feel which is only slightly spoiled by the lack of
ports, which makes the compartment a bit dark. With
an opening hatch and a mushroom ventilator thought,
there is plenty of air circulating. Stowage is
generous and consists of a unit with shelves and a
hanging locker plus shelves down the hull sides, as
well as some useful stowage aft of the water tank
under the bunk.
The heads are a reasonable size and well
equipped. There is sufficient floor area for
comfortable showering and easy access to seacocks.
Holding tanks, however, are extra.
The two aftercabins are more or less identical.
they have good standing areas and locker units and
shelves similar to those forward. the bunks are
1.95m (6ft 5in) long and 1.32m (4ft 4in) wide. The
port cabin has an additional, unusual and valuable
row of lockers let into the inboard bulkhead which,
apart from providing a small amount of general
stowage, gives access to batteries and their
switching gear and engine ancillaries.
The after head in our version is virtually
identical to that forward. If only one aftercabin is
required, the head gains a separate shower cubicle
and the cockpit an extra, very deep locker.
The galley is not quite as large as some 12m
boats can boast but it is perfectly adequately
equipped for extended cruising. This was, however,
one area where Dufour was still working out the
detail, but from what we could see there will be
plenty of structured stowage above and below the
work surfaces. the icebox, cooled by Frigoboat
compressor, is a generous size but was fitted with a
couple of rather nasty plastic boxes. An opening
port provides ventilation.
The navigator has a big, wrap-around table with
plenty of instrument space, including a special
console for radar and plotter. There is a bookshelf
and stowage lockers for bosunry and tools, and a big
bin under the navigator's seat.
Overall, we felt the interior was well put
together and tidily finished. Headroom throughout is
generous, varying little from 1.97nm (6ft 5in) in
the saloon to 1.94m (6ft 4in) in the cabins. The
design manages the trick of appearing to be spacious
as well as fully fitted.
On deck
The graceful rounded superstructure by Patrick
Roseo is narrow, leaving room for wide side decks
bounded by a teak toe rail and with long and secure
grab rails on the cabin top. Non-Slip is generally
good except on the curved coachroof edges. Deck
hardware, such as cleats, is adequate for normal
use. The bow roller, on the other hand, is not up to
serious cruising standards. Access to the cockpit
over low coamings is easy. The well is long and
wide, though narrowing towards the forward end,
where it is possible to use the leeward seat as a
foot brace. The seats themselves are quite low but
comfortably angled. The helmsman has a raised
central seat and comfortable wing seats as well as
moldings on the coamings, so he has plenty of
options. The central seat removes to give access to
the boarding platform. In the sole at the after end
of the cockpit there is very good access to steering
flats and to a liferaft locker.
The boat is rigged for short-handed sailing, with
the mainsheet traveller on the cockpit sole just
ahead of the binnacle and the genoa sheet winches
located right aft by the wheel. It is actually quite
difficult for the crew to handle the genoa sheets
and keep a good eye on the sail itself.
The binnacle is low, so the wheel, though not
exceptionally large, has to run in shallow groove in
the cockpit sole. The mainsheet, being so close to
the binnacle occassionally drops into the trough and
jams the wheel. The sailing instruments are
unusually (and in our view) incorrectly mounted on
either side of the binnacle, where they can be seen
by the helmsman if he is sitting on the coamings but
not if he is behind the wheel.
The general stowage lockers under the cockpit
seats are on the small side in the version with two
aftercabins. The gas-bottle locker is also compact,
with room for two small bottles. Fortunately, the
chain locker in the foredeck is larger than normal
and can act as a fender store. It also contains a
manual windlass.
She is nine-tenths rigged, with the mast set well
forward and supported by twin spreaders, with
discontinuous upper, intermediate and after lower
shrouds. An inner forestay is an option. The genoa
is small and easily managed. Even so, Dufour has
generously provided Harken 48 self-tailing winches
to handle the sheets. The rest of the deck gear, by
Harken and Spinlock, is well up to the job except,
possibly, the pair of Harken 40 halyard winches on
the coachroof. Those of normal strength might prefer
Harken 42's. The standard inventory includes a short
battened main and roller furling for the genoa.
Under Sail
Over the two days of trials we experience a range
of conditions from flat calm to Force 5, providing a
good, all round test for the boat. We began, though,
by gilling around in the approaches to La Rochelle
hunting for the weakest zephyrs. With little more
than six to eight knots blowing, we kept her fairly
free (around 40º to the apparent wind) and managed
to build up an impressive boat speed of 4.7 to five
knots. This proved to be by far her best point of
sailing in these conditions. Before we had a chance
to do any serious windward work, though, the wind
packed its bags for the day. The helm was, not
surprisingly, very light, but also very positive.
Helming the boat from the coamings where you need to
be to read the instruments, the wheel was a long
arm's reach away and we were pleased to hear that
Dufour are planning to raise the binnacle and
install a bigger wheel.
Day two began with a little more breeze in which
we made 5.5 knots at 60º to wind with almost neutral
helm. Coming up to 45º, the apparent wind rose to 11
to 13 knots and she accelerated to 6.5 knots. The
wind continued to build until we were topping eight
knots in 16 knots of apparent wind. The log
eventually peaked at 8.5 knots in 18 knots apparent.
Hard on the wind, she slipped into a comfortable
groove from the start with just the lightest
pressure on the fingers. At 30º to the wind we made
between 6.5 and seven knots in winds between 16 and
19 knots apparent and tacked through 85º. She came
through the wind quickly and was soon back in her
stride without the need to bear away to regain
speed. Even in the strongest winds, weather helm was
no more than a gentle pressure and the angle of heel
was around 20º. We felt no need to reef in this wind
strength and she stood up to her canvas well.
Downwind, we retained good control and she came
through the gybe cleanly. Heaving-to proved
disappointing: she lay very beam-on and made half a
knot or more of leeway.
The overall impression of the two days, though,
was of a boat with loads of performance potential,
perhaps rather restrained by her sail handling
lay-out, which is aimed at the average family crew
rather than racing teams. She would be an
interesting boat to rig for fully crewed sailing
with the optional deep draft lead keel and a full
set of tweaking goodies. She could just prove to be
a flier. As she was, though, she was still a fast
but delightfully easy to handle and a pleasure to
steer. Her stability curve shows an angle of
vanishing stability which is on the low side, but in
normal sailing conditions she felt stiff.
Under Power
Our boat was fitted with a Volvo 55 hp diesel in
place of the standard 40 hp sail drive. The
installation was smooth enough, but a noisy engine
room fan and limited sound proofing rather spoiled
the effect.
Fifty-five horsepower is more than the boat
needs. We recorded over eight knots at just below
full revs with speed actually falling off under full
power as the stern dug in. An economical cruising
speed was just over seven knots, at 2,500 rpm. we
feel sure that the 40 hp unit will do just about the
same.
She handled reliably ahead and astern, even in a
strong cross wind. Her turning circles are tight and
she showed very little preference for port or
starboard turns - there should be very few nasty
surprises when manoeuvring in tight corners.
Verdict
We were impressed by this new design, which seems
to strike a good balance between performance, easy
handling, comfort and spaciousness. The Dufour
factory, which we visited, is modern in its methods
and appears to be producing hulls which are rigid
and interiors which are close fitting and well
finished.
The standard inventory is reasonably
comprehensive. A"Cruiser" pack and basic electronics
options are available.
Dufour was once Europe's biggest builder, but
subsequently declined to the point where it rented
out most of its extensive factory buildings. It was
good to see that the company is again in full
possession of its facilities.
Technical Specifications & Options (UK Pricing
not reproduced below)
Options
»Cruiser pack (incl electric
windlass, battery charger, seawater foot pump,
stereo radio/DC, boarding gates, warps, fenders,
Dufour Crockery for eight.
»Electronics pack (incl 2 x ST60
wind, 2 x Tridata ST60, multi, Furuno GPS, Autopilot
»Performance Pack No longer
available - Individual options available to build a
performance package
»Other Options See US options lists
Construction
The hulls are laid using chopped
strand mat and woven rovings, Isophthalic,
osmosis-resistant resins are used for the gel coat
and first laminate. Above the waterline, a PVC foam
core is vacuum bagged in place, and below the
waterline a structural tray of floors and stringers
is bonded and laminated to the hull. The PVC cored
deck is one of the largest to be made by a
production boat builder using resin transfer molding
techniques, which the company is pioneering. The
result is a light structure with a high finish
inside and out. The hull and deck are mechanically
fastened, then laminated together.
For:
»Lively performance
»Easy handling
»Good interior design
Against:
»Some interior detailing to be improved
»Gas bottle storage
»Deck and sail handling layout not ideal for full
crews
_______________________________________________________________________
This article was written by James Jermain, and
published in the January 2003 issue of Yachting
Monthly in the UK. Photos similar to those published
in the article are used here.
_______________________________________________________________________
MANUFACTURERS NOTES: (from Dufour USA)
(1) Holding Tanks are included in US Specifications
and pricing.
(2) Electric Windlass is standard in US
Specifications and pricing.
(3) Options Packaging may differ in the US - i.e.
Cruiser Pack is Standard in US and included in
pricing.
|